The answer is closer than you think.
I know this is not something to joke about, but whenever I think about it, one line from a Batman movie comes to mind. Harvey Dent says it in The Dark Knight, before he becomes Two-Face:
“You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.”
I always thought that line was about heroes and villains. Lately, I think it is about the stairs.
I have studied abroad for quite a few years, and almost every country I have been to has spaces in public areas built specifically for physically challenged people. Spaces that help them feel like a part of the community.
When I studied in Dubai and Syracuse, the buses had a section set aside just for them. And whenever the bus stopped for someone in a wheelchair, the driver would stop everything. He would get up from his seat, step down from the bus, pull out the ramp, and make sure the person was buckled in and safe. Only then would he go back to his seat and carry on.
Many countries do this.
So let me ask you a question, one I will spend this entire article trying to answer.
Who is the ramp really for?
One Metre Lower
A couple of years back, I was a student in the United States, doing my Master’s. One day, I was on the bus from my apartment to the building where my classes were. I had music playing, and I was peacefully nodding my head along to the song.
That is when I noticed something I had not seen in a while. I had seen it in Dubai, but never quite like this. At one particular stop, an elderly man in a wheelchair was waiting to get on. The bus stopped, and the others got in.
Then the driver pressed a button, and the whole bus lowered itself, just a little, towards the pavement. He got up from his seat, went to the door, and opened a latch at the bottom of the step we had all just climbed. It folded out into a ramp. He walked down to the pavement, gently brought the elderly man on board and into the wheelchair section, and buckled him in himself. He made sure he was strapped in nice and safe, and asked him if he was alright.
Only then did he go back to his seat and carry on with the journey.
It was a simple gesture from the driver, but it meant something. It made me smile a little. And keep in mind, this is coming from someone who complains that the elevator is too slow, and is too lazy to take the stairs.
The Airport
Now, anyone who has travelled, locally or abroad, knows a few things about boarding a flight. Before anyone else is allowed on, the crew makes sure people in wheelchairs and other physically challenged passengers board first, so they are settled and comfortable. Only then does everyone else board.
We could keep talking about all the good things, all the progress. But I wouldn’t be doing my duty as a storyteller if I did not tell you what led to that progress.
In February 2024, an 80 year old man and his wife landed in Mumbai on an Air India flight. Both of them had booked wheelchairs in advance. But because of a shortage at the airport, there was only one, and he let his wife use it. He chose to walk beside her, about 1.5 km, all the way to the immigration counters. There, he collapsed. He was rushed to a hospital, but was declared dead. The DGCA fined Air India ₹30 lakh for the incident.
Similarly, in May 2022, IndiGo staff in Ranchi stopped a specially abled teenage boy from boarding the Ranchi to Hyderabad flight, saying he looked visibly in a state of panic. A DGCA probe found the staff had handled it badly and made the situation worse. It noted that a few compassionate words and a little kindness from the staff would have calmed the child. In fact, there were fellow passengers, including doctors on board, who were ready to help, but the staff declined. The DGCA fined IndiGo ₹5 lakh.
But India did learn from these incidents. By December 2024, all 35 of India’s international airports had ramps, accessible toilets and dedicated help desks, so that a situation like this does not happen again.
To be fair, mishandling does not just happen in India.
US airlines together mishandled 11,527 wheelchairs in 2023 alone. In October 2024, American Airlines was fined $50 million, 25 times bigger than any earlier fine of its kind, and a stronger rule followed in December 2024.
And in Europe, under EU law, it is the airport, not the airline, that must give disabled passengers free assistance.
We all think getting off the plane is the easy part. That is only until we hear the full story.
The Stairs
India is improving.
The Hyderabad Metro has taken care of quite a few things: lifts with low buttons, wide gates for wheelchairs, tactile paving from the street to the platform, and reserved seats on every train that comes and goes. But there is a catch. The challenge is reaching it. The last 200 metres before the station: a broken footpath, a high kerb, a parked vehicle.
And across India, only about 6% of buses are fully accessible, along with 709 railway stations.
In 2022, only 126 of New York’s 472 subway stations were accessible. A court settlement promised that 95% of them would be accessible by 2055. That means a child born today will be 29 years old by then. Not just that, advocates counted at least 25 elevator outages a day.
In London today, about 95 Tube stations are step free, roughly a third of them. The goal is half by 2030.
In Singapore, every MRT station is barrier free, and so are 98% of bus stops.
So the world is improving and learning. But we always need to remember: a lift is only as good as the road that leads up to it.
The Paperwork
According to a 2022 WHO report, 1.3 billion people, that is 1 in 6 of us, live with a significant disability. India’s 2011 census counted only 2.21% of us, about 2.68 crore people.
We do not have fewer disabled people. We just have fewer counted.
But the law has not ignored them. The RPwD Act 2016 reserves 4% of government jobs and 5% of higher education seats. Not only this, over 1.31 crore disability ID cards, called UDID cards, have been issued.
But the reality is something completely different. A law on paper does not lift a wheelchair.
Young and Old
So far, I have been talking about buses, airports and metro stations. But who are the people actually trying to use them? A child who can’t climb the stairs to the school building. A grandfather who can’t climb the steps to the temple.
Let’s start with the children.
According to UNICEF, almost 240 million children around the world live with a disability. That is 1 in every 10 children. And compared to other children, they are 49% more likely to have never been to school at all.
Never. Not dropped out. Never walked through the gate.
And here in India, we can’t even say for sure how many of our children are in that number. Remember, we never counted them properly in the first place.
Now, this is the part that surprised me. Back in 1977, Italy closed its special schools. From then on, children with disabilities would study in the same classrooms as everyone else. Today, 99.6% of them do.
Read that again. 99.6%.
But keep in mind, being in the room is not the same as belonging in it. Some researchers in Italy point out that the support teacher sometimes becomes “a special teacher for a special child”, sitting in the corner with one student while the rest of the class carries on. So even the best number in Europe has a story behind it.
Now let’s come to the other end.
In 2025, nearly 3 in every 10 people in Japan were over the age of 65. A record. So when Japan wrote its barrier free law, it did something very simple. It wrote it for the elderly and for persons with disabilities, together. Because sooner or later, they are the same people.
Think about your own grandparents for a second. The knee that doesn’t bend the way it used to. The hand reaching for the railing. The extra minute it takes to get out of the car. Nobody in our house would ever call them disabled. But the stairs don’t know that.
And this is the part that really stayed with me. This is the only group in the world that any of us can join, on any day. An accident. An illness. Or just enough birthdays.
Our grandparents are already members.
We just never called them that.
The People Around Them
In December 2015, the Prime Minister proposed a new word, “Divyang”, which translates to divine body. And what was the reply? In January 2016, a group of disabled people’s organisations wrote back: disability is not a divine gift.
So is disability a matter of charity, or a right? We often see it as an inspiration, or as a chance for seva. But we forget that it is a right, not just something for us to be inspired by. The 2016 law says so clearly.
So what is India’s strength? Our sense of community and family. The neighbour who lifts a wheelchair up a step without being asked, saying, “Uncle, let me help.”
There are small things all of us around them can do. Ask before you push someone’s wheelchair. Speak to the person, not their companion. And never park on a ramp or a footpath.
The Ramp Was Always for Us
Now here is the thing I did not expect to find at the end of all this.
The ramp was never only for them.
In the 1970s, wheelchair users in Berkeley, California pushed their city to cut small slopes into the kerbs at street corners. Just a little dip in the footpath, so a wheelchair could roll from the road onto the pavement without someone having to lift it.
Now think about who uses those slopes today. A mother pushing a pram. A traveller dragging a suitcase. A delivery boy with a trolley full of boxes. Nobody stops to ask who fought for it. They just roll over it and keep going.
Years later, it got a name: the curb cut effect. Build something for the people who need it most, and somehow, it ends up helping everyone.
So I went looking for where it all began, and it took me to a hospital lawn in England.
On 29 July 1948, the same day the London Olympics opened, a doctor named Ludwig Guttmann held an archery contest at Stoke Mandeville Hospital. Sixteen injured servicemen and women, with bows in their hands.
Sixteen.
That lawn became the Paralympics. In Paris 2024, India came home with 29 medals, and Avani Lekhara became the first Indian woman to win two Paralympic golds. From a hospital lawn to a podium in Paris.
So, coming back to the question I started with. Who is the ramp really for?
After everything I read, I don’t think the difference between countries is only money. Rich countries break wheelchairs too. The difference is whether a country builds for everyone, or treats disability as charity for someone else.
That bus driver in Syracuse was not doing anyone a favour. He was doing his job, because somebody, long before him, decided the bus belonged to everyone.
And keep in mind what Harvey Dent said. Live long enough. In real life, you don’t become the villain. You become the person the stairs were never built for.
I still don’t know whose turn is next.
The Echo
The ramp outside my office was built for someone else. One day, it will be built for me.
We call them Divyang, physically challenged, special. Maybe the kinder word is simply neighbour.
Echos Of My Mind
A journey through thoughts and imagination
Find me here
Website: https://echosofmymind.com
WhatsApp Channel: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbDwX5a4CrfaTPyftQ1n
Facebook: https://facebook.com/echosofmymindofficial
LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/company/echosofmymindofficial
YouTube: https://youtube.com/@echosofmymindofficial
Instagram: https://instagram.com/echosofmymindofficial

Leave a Reply