The Cup That Stayed

A lone figure in a colourful dreamscape looking up at a whole, glowing old porcelain cup in the sky

What a 25 year old cup knows about branding

Behind the Name · Part 1 of 4

Imagine this: a beautifully designed cup with a logo printed on it, that looks very nice, but suddenly shatters into pieces. And beside it, a 25 year old cup. Not so intricate in design, but beautiful nevertheless.

That made me think. These are the same cups we use almost every day. Same hands, same people, same coffee or tea. So what did the old cup have that the new one did not?

Three Cups at Breakfast

A white Syracuse China cup with a peach lotus and pale green leaves, bought in 2000
The cup that stayed. Bought in 2000, still without a crack.

One day, a couple of days back, my family and I were sitting together having breakfast. While doing so, we decided to have some coffee, so we took out three cups, one for each of us at home. Mine was a promotional cup with a company’s logo on it. It looked very nice and very strong. The other two were smaller cups, but older ones.

After the coffee, my promotional cup, which was less than a year old, suddenly shattered into pieces. While picking them up, I counted sixteen pieces. The other two small cups, on the other hand, were bought in the year 2000. They are roughly 25 years old, and they were perfectly fine.

A speckled promotional cup with a dark rim, the same kind as the one that broke
A cup just like the one that broke.

So the funny thing is that a cup that looked so nice and so new could not last as long as a cup that is almost as old as I am. If looks meant quality, the cup that shattered should not have been the one year old cup. It should have been one of the older ones. So I did what I always do when something catches my curiosity: I went looking.

The Fire Remembers

I always thought a cup was just a cup. Clay, shaped, painted, done. Turns out, it is a lot more than that.

A cup starts as clay. Soft, wet, nothing special. Then it goes into the fire, and the fire slowly turns that clay into something closer to glass. How much of it turns depends on two things: how hot the fire is, and how long the cup stays in it.

That is where the difference begins.

Earthenware, the most basic kind, is fired at around 1,000 to 1,150°C. At that heat, the clay never fully turns into glass. It stays slightly porous, full of tiny gaps you can’t see. Stoneware goes higher, around 1,200 to 1,300°C, and comes out denser and stronger. And porcelain goes all the way up to about 1,400°C, where the clay fuses almost completely.

Now here is the part that got me. Good tableware is not fired once. It is fired twice. The first firing hardens it, the second one sets the glaze, and each one takes hours. It heats up slowly and cools down slowly.

Some modern ware skips all that. One firing, done fast. Faster means more cups a day. More cups a day means cheaper cups. Nothing wrong with that on paper.

But a rushed cup carries that rush inside it. The body of the cup and the glaze on top expand at different rates when they heat up. If they were not matched properly, or if the firing left tiny cracks inside, nobody would see them. Not the factory, not the company that gave it away, and not me when it was handed to me. They just sit there and wait. And then one day, someone pours in hot coffee.

Sixteen pieces.

So I went back and looked at the old cups again. Twenty five years. No crack, no chip, not even a hairline.

The old cups weren’t lucky. They were patient.

That got me thinking. If this happens to something as simple as a cup, where else does it happen?

That question took me to Geneva, a little over a hundred years ago.

On 23 December 1924, the biggest light bulb makers in the world sat down at one table. Osram, Philips and the overseas arm of General Electric were among them. Together they formed what came to be called the Phoebus cartel.

You would think a meeting like that was about making better bulbs. It was not.

At the time, a good bulb could last anywhere between 1,500 and 2,500 hours. The cartel agreed that from then on, bulbs would last 1,000 hours. Not more.

Read that again. They got together to make their own product worse.

And they took it seriously. Members had to send sample bulbs to a testing lab in Switzerland. If your bulbs lasted too long, you paid a fine. Think about that for a second. Somewhere in the world, a company was being punished for making something that worked too well.

There is even a letter. In 1927, Tokyo Electric, the company that later became Toshiba, wrote that it had cut the life of its bulbs from 2,500 hours to 1,600, and that it expected to sell more bulbs because of it.

They didn’t even hide it. They put it in writing.

The cartel finally fell apart around 1939, when the Second World War broke it up. The cartel was gone. The idea was not.

Now here is the funny part. While all of this was going on, there was a light bulb in a fire station in Livermore, California, that simply never got the memo. It was put up in 1901, and it is still burning. In 2015, it crossed one million hours.

Before you get too excited, there is a catch. It started as a 60 watt bulb. Today it gives off about 4 watts, roughly as much as a night lamp. So yes, it lasted. But it barely does its job anymore. Long life and good light don’t always come together, and to be fair to the bulb makers, that is still their argument today.

Still, that was 1924. Surely things have changed since then?

I wanted to believe that. So I kept looking.

In 2016, Germany’s environment agency asked the same question I was asking: are our things breaking sooner than they used to? They studied fridges, washing machines and other large appliances. In 2004, 3.5% of these were replaced within five years because they broke. By 2012/13, that number was 8.3%. More than double, in under ten years.

And here is the strange part. About a third of the appliances people replaced were still working. We weren’t just losing things. We were also throwing away things that were fine.

To be fair, the study did not find proof that companies were designing things to break. Most of the time, it isn’t some secret meeting in Geneva. It is speed. It is cost. It is the next new model looking better than the one we already have.

And honestly, that bothered me more.

Because it means nobody needed to plan for my cup to break.

Somebody only had to stop caring if it lasted.

What the Name Was Worth

So coming back to my cup. Why did it look so good and break so easily?

Because it was made to be given away. Most promotional cups are made to carry a logo, not to last. They have to look nice on the day they are handed over. What happens after that is nobody’s problem.

And honestly, a lot of us judge things the same way. If it looks good, it must be good. When the German environment agency released that study, its own president said that even price is not a reliable sign of quality. So not the looks, and not the price tag. Neither of them can really tell you how long something will last.

What can? A name, but only if there is something real behind it. And if you want proof of that, look at Japan.

Today, if you see “Made in Japan” on something, you trust it. Cars, cameras, electronics. But in 1950, it meant the exact opposite. Japanese goods were known around the world as cheap things, made from cheap materials, that broke easily. “Made in Japan” was almost a joke.

That July, a group of Japanese scientists and engineers invited an American statistician named W. Edwards Deming to speak to their industry leaders about quality. He told them something that sounded impossible at the time. If they followed his methods, he said, they would be competing with the best in the world within five years.

Years later, he said that in 1950, he was the only man in Japan who believed it.

To be fair, he wasn’t the only one teaching quality in Japan, and it didn’t happen in five years either. The world really started to notice only in the 1970s. But it happened. In 1951, Japan started giving out a prize in his name, the Deming Prize. In 1965, one of the companies that won it was Toyota.

Think about that. Same country, same words on the label. Only what was behind them changed.

Japan didn’t change its name. It changed what was behind it.

Today, the rest of the world is catching up, but in a very different way. From 31 July 2026, new right to repair rules started applying across the European Union. Companies now have to make it easier to fix things instead of replacing them. If you choose a repair while your product is still under warranty, you even get an extra year of guarantee.

Governments now need laws to make things last. Our old cups did it without any law at all.

So, coming back to the question I started with. What did the old cups have that the new one did not?

It wasn’t the look. It wasn’t the design.

So I turned one of the old cups over. On the bottom, in small black letters, it said: Royal Rideau, Fine China, Syracuse China Company, USA.

Syracuse. Of all the places, the same city where I did my Master’s.

The bottom of the old cup, stamped Royal Rideau, Fine China, Syracuse China Company, USA
The bottom of the old cup: Royal Rideau, Syracuse China Company, USA.

I looked it up. Syracuse China started in 1871 in New York, as the Onondaga Pottery Company. It made china for hotels, restaurants, trains and ships. Places where cups get knocked around, dropped and washed again and again. Back in 1886, it gave a guarantee that its glaze would not crack, the first of its kind on American tableware. Even the name on the bottom, Royal Rideau, is what they called their fully vitrified china. Clay fired until it was almost glass.

So the old cup was the branded one after all. But Syracuse didn’t earn its name by printing it on the bottom. It earned it in the fire.

So somewhere in Syracuse, someone let those cups sit in the fire long enough. Someone checked them before they left. Someone cared whether they would last.

I will never know who that person was.

But here is the part that stopped me. In April 2009, after 138 years, the Syracuse China factory closed. Its owner shut it down to cut costs and moved production elsewhere. 275 people lost their jobs, many of them after more than twenty years there.

The cups are still here. The factory that made them is not.

The Echo

We used to buy things once. Now we buy them again and again, and call it convenience.

Look around your home tonight. What has outlived its warranty, and do you know who made it?


Next in Behind the Name
For 25 years, the proof of that cup’s quality was printed right underneath it, and nobody in our house ever turned it over. How many things do we trust every day without ever checking?
That’s next, in Part 2 of Behind the Name: The Second Look.


Echos Of My Mind
A journey through thoughts and imagination

Find me here
Website: https://echosofmymind.com
WhatsApp Channel: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbDwX5a4CrfaTPyftQ1n
Facebook: https://facebook.com/echosofmymindofficial
LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/company/echosofmymindofficial
YouTube: https://youtube.com/@echosofmymindofficial
Instagram: https://instagram.com/echosofmymindofficial


Discover more from Echos Of My Mind

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Echos Of My Mind

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading