Nobody needed that cave painting. So why did someone make it?
9 min read
Today I want to ask you a question, and I will spend this article trying to answer it. Many of us have things we are good at. Some of us sing, some of us dance, some of us are brilliant artists, some of us are great orators. But why do we do it? Is it because we love it, or is there something deeper? Why do we check every word and every sentence two or three times before we hit send on an article? Why do our hands shake when we give a speech or pitch our business?
The Moment Before
I started writing a long time ago. It started when I visited Himachal Pradesh in the sixth grade. Before we left, my mom sat me down and said, “Ajitesh, seeing is one thing, remembering is completely different. What you see now, you might not remember. But if you write about it, if you write about how you felt, you will never forget.”
And so I did, for a long time. But then school, work and eventually life caught up with me. One day I was talking to a friend and told her that this is what I want to do, but I was nervous about whether it would work out. She said only one thing: “Take a deep breath and just go for it. If it happens, it happens. You’re already working, so what’s there to lose?”
I have another friend who I met at a business meeting, and she soon became a very close friend of mine. Aside from her business, she draws, she paints, and she even goes for drawing classes. In fact, she was one of the people who pushed me to start writing again after I had stopped. One thing I have always noticed about her is that no matter how many headaches she has in life, she is always smiling. She always seems to be at peace. Maybe that is why she has always been one of my favourite people.
But being that way is not easy. There are a lot of things you have to work through, and maybe sometimes we hide a few of them to get there.
And it’s not just me, or the people around me. When I started reading about this, I realised we are only the latest in a very long line.
On an island in Indonesia called Sulawesi, there is a cave wall with a painting of a wild pig and a few human-like figures around it. It was dated in 2024, and it is at least 51,200 years old. Someone stood in that cave, in the dark, and decided this moment was worth putting on a wall.
Go back even further. In Blombos Cave in South Africa, researchers found a small piece of stone with crossed lines drawn on it in red ochre. It is around 73,000 years old. It doesn’t mean anything we can read. Someone just wanted to make a mark.
Music is not far behind. In caves in southern Germany, archaeologists found flutes made from bird bone and mammoth ivory, about 42,000 years old. Somebody sat down and carved holes into a bone just so they could play a tune.
Then in 2019, a team of researchers looked at societies all across the world, and every single one of them had music.
It Makes No Sense
Now, people on the other side of the stage only see their side of it. There is another side that stays hidden: the creator’s side. Creating anything costs time, sometimes money too, and usually there is no earning from it. Business people would call this return on investment, or ROI for short.
On top of that, performing in any form terrifies us. In a survey of 2,122 professional orchestral musicians, stage fright was the most common problem they reported. Reviews put performance anxiety at anywhere between 16.5% and 60%.
So why would anyone put themselves through that? Even science doesn’t have one answer.
Charles Darwin thought music started as a way to attract a partner, the same way a peacock shows off its tail. Much later, Geoffrey Miller took that idea further. According to him, making something difficult and beautiful is a way of showing off a good mind. The fact that art looks useless is the whole point. You’re showing that you can afford to spend your time on it.
Ellen Dissanayake, an American scholar, had a gentler idea. She said humans have a need to take something ordinary and make it special. A pot gets a pattern. A name becomes a song. She traced it all the way back to the way a mother talks and sings to her baby.
Then there’s Robin Dunbar at Oxford. In his studies, when people sang or danced together, their pain threshold went up and they felt closer to each other. For him, music and dance are how humans bonded in groups too big for everyone to know each other personally.
Three answers from three very smart people, and none of them has fully convinced the others.
Honestly, that surprised me. We have been doing this for fifty thousand years, and we still can’t agree on why.
Why We Do It Anyway
So even with all of this, why do we still do it?
First, it feels good. And I mean that literally. In 2011, a group of researchers in Montreal played people their favourite music while scanning their brains. At the moment the song hit its peak, the part where you get goosebumps, their brains released dopamine. That is the same chemical that shows up with good food and the other things we need to survive. But here is the part I liked. The dopamine was also there a few seconds before the peak, just in the waiting. So your dopamine rises at the peak of a song, and even while you’re waiting for the bass to drop.
It works the same way when you make something. When someone tells you that you wrote a good article, it’s more than motivation. It makes you want to do more, and it keeps you calm.
Second, something happens to the voice in your head. You know the one. It tells you this line is not good enough, that people will judge you, that you should just delete it and move on.
In 2008, two researchers at Johns Hopkins put jazz pianists inside a brain scanner and asked them to play in two ways. First a piece they had memorised, then something they made up on the spot. When they improvised, the part of the brain that watches and criticises everything we do went quiet, and the part linked to expressing ourselves became more active. In simple words, when you are really creating, your inner critic turns its volume down.
There is a name for where that leads. A psychologist called Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi called it flow. It is when you are so into something that you lose track of time. The task is hard enough to hold your attention, but not so hard that you give up. You stop worrying about how you look. You are just doing it.
Maybe that is what I see in my friend when she paints. Whatever is going on in her life, for those few hours, the noise stops.
Third, it pulls us together. We already saw that singing and dancing in a group makes people feel closer, but it goes further than a feeling. In 2013, researchers in Sweden studied people singing in a choir and found that their heart rates began to rise and fall together, following the way the song made them breathe.
Maybe that is why a stage feels so frightening and so good at the same time. For those few minutes, you are connected to everyone in the room. That is a big reason people walk back on stage even after their hands shook the first time.
Fourth, it helps us make sense of our lives. This one took me back to my mom. In 1986, a psychologist named James Pennebaker asked a group of students to write about the most difficult things they had been through, fifteen minutes a day for four days. In the months after, those students visited the health centre less than the ones who wrote about everyday topics. Later studies found the effect is real, but smaller than first thought. Still, I find it amazing. My mom told me that writing would help me remember. Turns out it can help you heal a little too.
The arts seem to be good for us in the long run as well. A study in England followed more than 6,000 people over the age of fifty for fourteen years. Those who went to museums, the theatre or concerts every few months or more had a 31% lower risk of dying during that time. The researchers were clear that this does not prove the arts caused it. But it is hard to ignore.
And then there are children. Nobody teaches a child to pretend. From around a year and a half, children everywhere start doing it. A banana becomes a phone, a box becomes a car. They draw on walls. They sing songs that make no sense. Nobody asks them to. It is in us from the start.
Which brings me back to that cave.
At the end of the day, every person wants one thing: something to leave behind. Your legacy. In 1973, a writer named Ernest Becker wrote a whole book about this. He said that because we know our time is limited, we look for something that will last longer than us. A song, a painting, a story, a business, a family. The person in Sulawesi probably never imagined we would be looking at their painting fifty thousand years later. But they left it anyway.
Maybe that is the real answer. We make things so that someone, somewhere, knows we were here.
The Echo
My mom told me that if I wrote it down, I would never forget. Fifty thousand years later, we are still looking at what someone painted on a cave wall. What will you leave behind?
Echos Of My Mind
A journey through thoughts and imagination
Find me here
🌐 Website: echosofmymind.com
💬 WhatsApp Channel: Join the channel
📸 Instagram: @echosofmymindofficial
📺 YouTube: @echosofmymindofficial
📘 Facebook: Echos Of My Mind
💼 LinkedIn: Echos Of My Mind

Leave a Reply